How to Screen a Marketing Manager Resume: Must-Haves, Red Flags and a Scoring Rubric
Marketing CVs are where vague results live: awareness raised, engagement increased, brand built. Screen for numbers tied to money or pipeline, for budgets owned, and for the mix of hands-on skill and management your role actually needs.
- Read for evidence before matching keywords: a marketing manager CV should show what the candidate built, ran, closed or decided, with a result. The must-haves below are the four things the job cannot be done without.
- Must-haves: campaigns or programmes with a goal, a budget and a result in leads, pipeline, revenue or cost; a budget figure owned, and what it was spent on. Nice-to-haves raise a candidate; they do not rescue one missing a must-have.
- Red flags are patterns, not single lines: results in impressions, followers and 'engagement' only, and no budget figure anywhere.
- Use the five-criterion rubric on the page, weighted so that results tied to money counts more than job description match. It is written to be pasted into WadeCV as a role and scored automatically.
- Spend three minutes per CV with the rubric and write one line of evidence per criterion. Screening decisions with evidence attached can be explained to the candidate, to the hiring manager, and to anyone who audits them later.
Must-haves
- Campaigns or programmes with a goal, a budget and a result in leads, pipeline, revenue or cost
- A budget figure owned, and what it was spent on
- Channels that overlap the role's: paid, content, email, events, product marketing, as required
- Some hands-on skill named and evidenced (writing, analytics, an ads platform, design tools)
Nice to have
- Measurement literacy: attribution, experiments, cohort analysis
- Sales alignment: lead definitions, feedback loops, joint targets
- Agency and vendor management with outcomes
- Experience at your company stage and audience (B2B, B2C, developer)
Red flags
- Results in impressions, followers and 'engagement' only
- No budget figure anywhere
- Every campaign 'exceeded expectations' with no expectation stated
- Job titles that grow while the bullets stay the same
The rubric
Score each criterion from what the CV shows; weight 3 counts three times weight 1. In WadeCV, create the role with these criteria and every CV is scored this way automatically.
| Criterion | How to measure it | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Job description match | Match between channels, audience, stage and the role as written | 2 |
| Years of relevant experience | Years running campaigns with a budget and a target, not total years in marketing | 2 |
| Results tied to money | Leads, pipeline, revenue or cost outcomes with numbers | 3 |
| Budget ownership | Budgets managed and allocated, with a stated size | 2 |
| Hands-on skill | At least one craft skill evidenced by work, not by a list | 1 |
How to read the CV
Find the money. Pipeline generated, cost per lead, revenue attributed, budget managed: a marketing manager who was measured on business outcomes writes them down. One who was measured on activity writes down the activity, and that tells you what kind of team they came from.
Check that the budget and the results are proportionate. A $2M pipeline from a $10k budget is either an exceptional story you should hear at interview or an attribution claim you should question.
Decide before screening how hands-on the role is, and score the hands-on skill accordingly. In a small team the manager writes, runs the ads and reads the analytics; a CV that shows only briefing and reviewing will not fit that, however senior.
Frequently asked questions
Should we screen for our industry?
Screen for the audience and the motion (B2B mid-market, developer, consumer). Industry knowledge follows quickly; audience intuition does not.
How do we assess a marketing generalist against a specialist role?
Score the specialist channel on the rubric and note the rest. Generalists often make excellent small-company marketing managers if the specialist channel is one of the things they have done well, not merely touched.
Are marketing certifications meaningful?
Platform certifications (ads, analytics) show the candidate can operate the tool; they say nothing about judgement. Score the campaigns.
Related guides
- How to Screen a Product Manager Resume: Must-Haves, Red Flags and a Scoring Rubric
- How to Screen a Sales Development Representative Resume: Must-Haves, Red Flags and a Scoring Rubric
- How to Screen a Data Analyst Resume: Must-Haves, Red Flags and a Scoring Rubric
- How to Screen a UX Designer Resume: Must-Haves, Red Flags and a Scoring Rubric
Screening marketing manager CVs this week?
Paste the job description into WadeCV, check the rubric it drafts, and upload the CVs. Each one is read against the rubric and scored with an explanation. Ten screenings are free; there is no subscription.
Screen your first CVs free